What Depression Means to Me: Neither This Nor That


Gentle Reader,

Though clinical depression is a distinct physical problem, it is definitely fueled by emotional issues. One of these issues, for me, is a nagging sense of never being able to fit in. Of never feeling comfortable in my surroundings or within my social/family group. This is partly due to the fact that I’ve learned how to be annoying ingratiating (i.e – a stereotypical and severe people pleaser), but it also comes from the fact that, well, I don’t exactly fit in anywhere. Now, I realize that everyone struggles with this to one extent or another, but experience up to this point as often affirmed my place outside the circle.

For example:

1. Politics – “Christian = Republican.”

I have a secret: I’ve never voted straight Republican. Ever.

I have another secret: I’ve never voted straight Democratic. Ever.

2. Christianity – “It’s not a religion, it’s a relationship.”

This cliche drives me absolutely bonkers. Do I have a relationship with Jesus Christ? Yes, I do. But I most definitely have a religion, which is defined as:

a set of beliefs concerning the cause, nature, and purpose of the universe, especially when considered as the creation of a superhuman agency or agencies, usually involving devotional and ritual observances, and often containing a moral code governing the conduct of human affairs…a specific fundamental set of beliefs and practices generally agreed upon by a number of persons or sects

I’m willing to bet that you have a religion, too.

We Christians, particularly those of us within the Protestant vein, have got to stop being afraid of this word. We’re so jumpy about appearing “Catholic” (the worst possible thing in the world that we could be perceived as, of course) that we distance ourselves from the sacred. We downgrade our interaction with God to something common and ordinary. Prayer becomes nothing more than chatting with Buddy Jesus. Bible study revolves around proving political ideology rather than opening our ears to hear what God has to say.

Isn’t there some sort of midway point between this lax attitude and that of intense formality? Isn’t it possible to know Christ as Best Friend but also as Supreme King? There has to be. Perhaps if we were more willing to explore the part of the definition highlighting “devotional and ritual observances,” we would find it.

(As a side note, I have begun to occasionally make the Sign of the Cross when I pray. Also, if I had the money,  I would want to buy this prayer shawl).

3. Marriage – “Women need love. Men need respect.”

Women and men require love. Men and women require respect.

I would not feel that my husband loved me at all if he didn’t respect my thoughts and feelings. It means a great deal to me that we discuss things, whether its finances, politics, theology or what to have for dinner. Even if he completely disagrees with me, I highly value the fact that he considers it important to ask me what I think. Knowing Chris as I do, I’m pretty sure that he wouldn’t feel respected if I didn’t take the time to do little “lovely” things like leave him notes or make him breakfast.

I don’t know much about marriage, but I know that it’s not an either/or.

4. The sexes – “Men are visual, women are emotional/relational.”

I acknowledge that there is a large slice of truth here. However, I’m a visual creature. God did give me eyes, right? I like it when my man dresses up all fine and puts on that cologne I love. This whole visual thing goes farther than just human appearance, though. There are times when we both pause to appreciate the beauty of a sunset or sigh with contentment at the sight of a clean house.

Chris is quite emotional. That doesn’t make him a weakling. In fact, it is my opinion that he’s all the stronger for knowing exactly how he feels and being comfortable enough to express it. He’s like David, the Warrior Poet. This is an area in which I have a lot to learn from my husband.

What I’m trying to say here is that I’m weary of attempting to fit myself into these narrow, predefined boxes. It doesn’t work. If I’m going to be outside the circle, I want to be content with that position. It means…well, I guess it means that I think for myself. Maybe it’s good to be neither this nor that, but to instead be…me.

My journey to faith. (15)

 For all the posts in the What Depression Means to Me series, go here.


8 thoughts on “What Depression Means to Me: Neither This Nor That

  1. Marie, you are so on track! And yes, you need to be you. Jesus was. He was not intimated or controlled or manipulated by anyone and he does not want his children to be either. We are not “doormats” as some may think; in fact the wisdom of God is in the Bible especially in Proverbs. It teaches us how to get the wisdom of God and use it for his glory.


  2. Marie,

    I can relate to a lot of your comments about fitting in. I realized something of an antidote in my tendency to people-please.

    Much of my people-pleasing behaviors were my attempt to feel spiritually safe, I saw that I cannot get what I want from people – I can only get it from my faith in God and my practice of Catholicism.

    I am no longer worried if I make the sign of the cross in public before I eat. I am no longer fretting about how people view me or my life. I turn these fears over to God and pray for humility, grace and to remember that we are all precious and unique.

    Thank you for sharing.


    1. Thanks for sharing this, Cinhosa. It’s interesting that you talk about people pleasing in relation to feeling spiritually safe. I’ll have to ponder on that.


  3. Marie,
    I like your blog. Voting straight democrat or republican: I am a republican and have never voted a straight ticket either. However, being that said, I am this year. My belief has always been you need your tattle-talers. As far as Catholic/Protestant I am a convert to the Catholic Church. I lost several “Christian Protestant Friends” when I did. One friendship was of 16 years. As far as the rest of this post, I think you are okay and will visit again. God Bless, SR


    1. I don’t know why people get so knotted up over where their friends go to church. I figure that God is faithful to guide us to where He wants us to be.

      Thanks for your comment. Hope you do visit again!


  4. Seriously…have you been reading my mind? I’ve been wondering where all the “neither this nor that” people are. The little boxes are just too tight a fit, too frustrating to work with anymore. So then my question is, how do you live in a world that very much depends on those little boxes?



Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.